Whilst visiting the Lake Superior Zoo in Duluth a few weeks ago, I came across these festive window decals in the zoo's Safari Cafe. I didn't get a chance to photograph ALL of the decals, but what I captured should be adequate. My apologies for the blurriness - I took 'em with no flash and on an empty stomach. I suggest clicking on each image to enlarge for better detail:



As you may or may not have noticed, these costumed critters seem familiar. But I can't quite put my finger on it... hmmmmmmm.Hey, wait a minute! I know now! Whad'ya know...
If you haven't figured it out by now, witness the BLATANT rip-off of cartoon animals taken from the famous Preston Blair Animation instructional book. The 'artist' behind these cute little Halloween characters isn't alone, unfortunately. Check out some of these old posts - here (Ohio lottery ticket), Here (an Ohio school mascot), and HERE (Australian restaurant ad) - over at Cartoon Brew, and you'll totally see what I mean! Of course, what I'm about to show you triumphs over all of these aforementioned one-offs. Not only do these Halloween drawings steal from Preston Blair in mass quantity, most of them might as well have been traced directly from the book itself, they're that obvious. And even THEN the artist managed to lose whatever perfect form the original drawings possess in the first place.
I have included scans from the Preston Blair book for comparison/double vision.
Look at that. EXACT pose, EXACT head shape, EXACT everything. Except for the lengthened tail on the mouse, the costume, and the pitchfork. Oh, and just to be on the safe side, a halo is added to ensure us that this cute little guy isn't promoting satanism in any shape or form (artist pun intended!). I should also point out that you will notice all of these Halloween drawings have altered scary giant green-colored iris eyes.
Hey, at least this one looks like the artist didn't do a direct carbon copy... although that's not really helping the situation. It now looks like a slightly melted version of Blair's, colorized! Badly!
Wow, huh? This one, on the other hand, IS a direct carbon copy. OH, but hold the phone!!! That darn cat is looking UP in the Halloween version! And that major alteration alone gives it character (pun!) all on its own. I noticed his eyes don't follow the line of action either (not saying it HAS to), but if you're designing crude non-animation holiday decals, who needs line of action anyway?
This one is rather interesting. It's some kind of super hybrid Franken-dog! He gets the special treatment - not ONE Preston Blair reference, but TWO! I included both references. The curve of the front leg, the expression of the dog's face. If you're gonna do direct copying, you might as well go nuts and mix it up a little. And look at that - instead of attaching the earring to the dog's actual ear, it's just part of the pirate hat! And that's safety. Kids, don't be piercing Rex's ear now! Do what the decal says!And, is that an oak leaf sticking out of his hat? Well, it IS changing colors just in time for Halloween I guess! This artist realizes that the little details matter.
Here is the other dog. And he's just as amazing as the previous pup! Another mashup of dogs! If only dog breeding were this easy in real life. Wouldn't it be cool to have a German Shepherd body, with say, a Chihuahua's head? Anyway, the artist took a big gamble by drawing the standing ear a SECOND time, and creating an ALL-NEW tail! And how about that nose? Seems fitting for a clown-dog. By the way, I hate clowns.
This one wasn't as obvious, and is the least noticeable... but I THINK I found the proper references in the Preston Blair book. First, if you look at the jester cat on the left, the mouth kind of gives it away for me. There are plenty of other drawings of this 'faux-Tom' cat in the book, but the Blair cat I included seemed to be the closest match. Now take a look at the bodies. The jester cat has the same legs as the Springer Spaniel on the right... likewise, the Elton John kitty seems to rip off the foundation of the Boston Terrier (or whatever it is). At least we have S-shaped cat tails, though. If those hadn't been drawn I don't know what kind of animals I'd be looking at!
I don't even have to explain this one. Sheesh.
And this one's just as bad! But what's going on with its hands? If you look at the Blair version, you can see that they're a cat's HANDS/PAWS. In the Halloween version, they look like grotesque webbed claws. I'm sure it's because he keeps getting his dirty little paws too close to that boiling cauldron of bubbling brew. See, even the pumpkin is trying to warn him not to make that mistake again.So there you have it. I'm sure some of you out there are speechless.
Now, while I let you finish shaking your head in disbelief, I have one last Halloween SCARE for you all! But be careful! It's not for the faint of heart. Here's the link. Just remember, I warned you...







14 comments:
If these things are decals, then they're being mass-produced, and I'm sure the Warren Foster folks would love to know that their property is being ripped off for profit.
You need a stronger warning before that last scary link. It it truly frightening! :0)
I don't think I ever visited the Duluth Zoo since it was rennovated and changed into the Lake Superior Zoo when I was in Junior High School. I do remember looking at it when riding the bus to Morgan Park...
Not surprised to see that all the cheap Halloween cutouts are blatant thefts from the Preston Blair book. It's one of those things that one pretty much expects from a weird little town like Duluth. We'll have to keep our eyes open for the Thanksgiving cutouts.
>>>If these things are decals, then they're being mass-produced, and I'm sure the Warren Foster folks would love to know that their property is being ripped off for profit.
I'd like to find a sheet of these decals in a store somewhere myself! I'll send 'em to Walter Foster and show them a thing or two (I assume you meant Walter, not Warren)! I wonder if these decals are old, or more recent?
>>>You need a stronger warning before that last scary link. It it truly frightening! :0)
I apologize - but sometimes I gotta expose that which is the ugly truth. :-)
The scary thing is that some kid is probably tracing these things thinking it's some kind of great reference!
Great post man.
daniel - That was the first time I've ever been there. I thought it was a really good zoo for its smaller size.
Louie - ain't that the truth! By the way, I checked out your website and it's one of the COOLEST Flash sites I've EVER seen! I'm also linking your blog ASAP!
Preston Blair rip-offs like these is a world-wide phenomenon. There are plenty of theme parks and fun fairs all over Europe featuring variations of his characters. I wish I had taken pictures whenever I saw one.
Great piece, very entertaining and funny. Thanks!
Good post Trevour. Until I read the old old Preston Blair book I never realized how often his work has been copied - in such hideous form.
But leave it to Ohio to be a culprit.
Well, back to copying Preston Blair...for education.
Ohhh....I found a place that sells the decals. I'm not sure if they are the ones that actually designed them, but there they are PB rip offs - for fun and profit!
Holy crap, Shaun, those ARE the decals!!! How did you ever find them? I may have to order some. Or refer the link to Walter Foster, maybe? :-)
I just did a quick Google search, and about a page or two in, I say this one advertising window clings and sure enough that was it.
You'd think since they love to rip other work, they'd steal a nice website design...
Stop calling the thief an ARTIST! He/she is nothing more than a human tracing paper ripoff artist... okay, I stand corrected. "Artist" works.
I'm willing to bet that these decals were drawn by some production artist in China or something like that, bogged down by a ton of work perhaps. Then the bigwigs in charge of the production of these stickers have no clue they were traced. Then off they go to whoever for distribution, and of course none of them know it's ripped off work either.
Or we can just blame some unknown guy for knowingly and directly trying to profit off someone else's art. It seriously could be true.
I'm not defending anybody, especially not a lazy ripoff artist, but I find these kinds of things amusing.
The site that is selling these www.superclings.com has an interesting blurb on how the decals are made and I quote,
" Super Signs has been producing holiday vinyl window clings Christmas decorations for 25 years. We have our own 14,000 sq ft building solely for designing and manufacturing of static vinyl cling window decoration decals.
Let these professional Christmas holiday decorations brighten your home during each holiday season. The Christmas holiday static vinyl cling window decoration decals are all original designs created by our own art department."
Now, if that art department is local or based in China, or someplace else is up in the air. But either way they are claiming these as original works!
hey but preston blair did it too. Check out this pic by hirschfeld and compare it to Blair's shoddy farmer design at the end of his book. http://theater.nytimes.com/ref/theater/hirschfeld/index.html?rf=person%2Fdetail_10.html
well i don't care about who got ripped off that much in this case it's so obvious and blatant, and degrading, i just think it's hilarious... great side by side comparisons!
Post a Comment